3-D Hurricane
Featured Expert View Bio

The United States faces an endless sea of red ink...

Boosted by waves of deficit spending, the U.S. Government’s official debt now tops 100% of Gross Domestic Product(GDP). Including the debt of Government Sponsored Enterprises (GSEs) and unfunded entitlements, the debt totals 460% of GDP.
See Graphic

...As do other developed markets

Other developed markets also face staggering debt burdens. Japan’s debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds 200%. Among the GIIPS countries of Greece, Ireland, Italy, Portugal, and Spain, all but the last have ratios topping 100%. And the bigger European economic powers also are saddled with high debt levels: Germany, France, and the United Kingdom are all approaching 90%. If off-balance sheet entitlements were included, those figures would be substantially higher.

Choices >>

3D-Public-Debt

High debt burdens pose real and severe risks

Research by economists Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff suggests that median growth rates drop by 1% for countries with a debt-to-GDP ratio exceeding 90%. Few countries recover after exceeding this 90% threshold, often collapsing under the weight of their obligations.

Debt-laden developed markets face unattractive options

Debt-laden developed markets have three choices, none of which are attractive. First, they can choose austerity, which causes a reduction in GDP as well as debt--a painful outcome for a country’s citizens. Second, some countries are forced to choose default or restructuring. Third, countries with control of the currencies and interest rates often adopt policies that deliberately suppress real interest rates. These policies often lead to steady inflation and negative real interest rates, which imply low returns on capital, weak economic growth, and high unemployment.

Emerging markets offer some hope

In contrast, emerging markets, with low debt and deficit levels and younger populations, appear far healthier economically and have strong growth prospects. They don’t encounter the headwinds facing developed markets.See Graphic

Unreal GDP >>

3-D Dev Markets

GDP measures spending, not prosperity

With the exception of exports, GDP measures spending—making no distinction between debt-financed spending and spending that we can cover with current income. It does not measure prosperity, and ignores the fact that we are mortgaging our future to feed current consumption.

Debt-financed consumption is misleading

If the government borrows an additional 5% of GDP and spends it immediately, GDP growth rises by 5%! This debt-financed consumption provides a misleading picture of the economy and a false sense of security. It is unreal GDP.

Structural GDP offers a better measure

Structural GDP—GDP net of new public borrowing—offers a far more accurate measure of prosperity. To net out the effects of population growth and inflation, real per capita Structural GDP tells the true story: Our prosperity is nearly unchanged since 1998.See Graphic

Demographics >>

3-D GDP

Developed countries are graying rapidly

Demographics only make the outlook worse, as populations in Japan, the United States, and Europe gray and the ratio of active workers to retirees shrinks. In the United States, there were five working adults for every retiree in 1970. Today, that ratio is 3.5 to 1 and, if the retirement age remains constant, that ratio is projected to drop below 2 to 1 by 2050, based on data from the U.S. Census and the United Nations.

Aging populations will slow growth

These demographic shifts will have substantial effects on the economy—a combination of increased inflation and interest rates, a rising trade deficit, slower GDP growth, delayed retirement, and increased immigration. The developed world may go from a period of high unemployment to a shortage of workers.

Emerging markets poised to benefit

Not only will aging populations cause GDP growth to slow, but retirees will sell off their assets—first stocks, then bonds—to finance their lifestyles. In contrast, much younger and relatively debt-free emerging markets stand to benefit from these changes.

Investments >>

3D-Demographics

Dramatic implications for investments

The 3-D Hurricane of unending deficits, massive debt, and unfavorable demographics has dramatic implications for investments. Combined, they will create a headwind for growth in developed markets and a surge in inflation, which hurts valuations for bonds and, to a lesser extent, for stocks.

Alternative assets can protect against inflation

Investors need to create a third pillar in their portfolios that provides protection from inflation. This pillar should focus on asset classes that will over the long term generate superior real returns, such as emerging markets stocks and bonds, high-yield bonds, bank loans, TIPs, and REITs. See Graphic

Investors must focus on the real risk

Investors must ask themselves: What is risk? Short-term volatility or long-term impairment of purchasing power? Unless one plans to spend the bulk of one’s assets in the next year or two, inflation represents the far greater risk.

Research >>

Investments

The following resources provide a deeper look into issues affecting 3-D Hurricane.

  • The “3-D” Hurricane Force Headwind

    Fundamentals
    November 2009 | Rob Arnott

    The U.S. deficit and national debt relative to GDP is vastly understated. Add in the long-term influence of an aging population and the outlook is bleaker still. Rising deficits, soaring deficits and changing demographics have drastic implications for inflation, stocks and bonds around the world.
    3-D Hurricane, Asset Allocation, Demographics

  • The 3-D Hurricane and the New Normal

    White Paper
    June 2011 | Jason Hsu

    Debt, deficit, and demographics—the 3-D hurricane—is heading to the shores of all developed economies. It threatens to derail the lukewarm economic recovery and to alter forever the heretofore path of robust growth for the developed world.
    3-D Hurricane

  • The Long View-Building the 3-D Shelter

    Fundamentals
    October 2011 | Rob Arnott

    In the long run, the combination of rising debts and deficits and aging demographics will create a 3-D hurricane affecting capital markets. Creating a "third pillar" to existing developed world equity and bond allocations should produce more meaningful real returns over a market cycle.
    3-D Hurricane, GTAA, Asset Allocation

  • Does Unreal GDP Drive Our Policy Choices?

    Fundamentals
    April 2011 | Rob Arnott

    Gross Domestic Product is used to measure a country’s economic growth and standard of living. It measures neither. Unfortunately, the finance community and global centers of power are wedded to a measure that bears little relation to reality because it confuses prosperity with debt-fueled spending.
    Asset Allocation

  • Debt Be Not Proud

    Fundamentals
    August 2010 | Rob Arnott

    We live in a world profoundly addicted to debt-financed consumption. When the debt comes due, borrowers will replace it with new debt. But this borrowing inevitably will end in tears. The looming sovereign debt crisis will be a defining influence on capital market returns over the next 10 years.
    3-D Hurricane, Bonds, RAFI, Smart Beta

  • Dirt Economics: Demographics Matter

    Fundamentals
    February 2012 | Shane Shepherd

    Generations ago, people had large families. Now, families are small and we face a mountain of debt and soaring deficits. The implications of these changing demographics include higher inflation and interest rates, and slower GDP growth. Investors should prepare for lower expected returns and higher inflation.
    3-D Hurricane, Demographics, Bonds, RAFI, Smart Beta

  • Institutionalizing Courage

    Fundamentals
    May 2012 | Rob Arnott

    Most people tend to measure wealth in terms of the dollar value of a portfolio. We believe it is better to measure wealth in terms of the real spending the portfolio can sustain over the entire life of the obligations served by the portfolio. We call this approach “sustainable spending.” But focusing on sustainable spending requires real courage.
    GTAA, RAFI, Equity, Fundamental Index, Smart Beta

  • Should You Be Concerned About the Government Debt

    Fundamentals
    March 2012 | Jason Hsu

    With U.S. government debt equal to 100% of GDP, should investors be concerned? What specifically makes high government debt-to-GDP bad? How much is “too much”? Does it matter whether the debtholders are domestic buyers or foreign buyers?
    3-D Hurricane, Asset Allocation

Fundamentals Subscription Fundamentals Subscription